M-210

The City of Toronto (the City) received identical requests from three persons, under the Municipal Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (the Act), for access to records in the possession or control of the City's Job Evaluation Division pertaining to the positions of Archivist and of Records & Information Analyst.

The City identified 122 records as being responsive to the request. The City granted full access to 25 records, partial access to 20, and denied access to 64 records. In denying access, the City claimed exemptions under sections 7, 11(c), (d), (e) and (f), and 14 of the Act. After receiving the comments of the President of the CUPE local (the Union) which had created or provided information contained in 13 of the records to the City, the City denied access to the 13 remaining records on the basis of section 10 of the Act. The three requesters appealed the City's decision to deny access to the records.

• MFIPPA
• 10(1)(a)
• 10(1)(c)
• 10(1)(d)
• 11(c)
• 11(d)
• 11(e)
• 14(1)(f)
• 14(3)(d)
• 14(4)(a)
• 2(1) personal information
• 7(1)

• Advice or Recommendations
• classification, salary range, benefits or responsibilities
• contractual negotiations
• education or employment history
• evaluations or performance reports
• information
• labour relations
• Personal Information (Definition)
• plans or positions
• reasonable expectation of harm
• undue loss or gain
• reasonable expectation of harm