Judicial Review of Provincial Orders

 
Order No. Status Citation
PO-4180 Institution’s application for judicial review – dismissed Office of the Independent Police Review Director v. Information and Brian Selig, Tor. Doc. #799/21 (Div. Ct.)
PO-4162 Affected Third Party’s application for judicial review pending Office of the Auditor General for Ontario  v. Information and John Doe, Requester, Tor. Doc. #637/21 ( Div. Ct.)
PO-4149 Affected Third Party’s application for judicial review pending Uber v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario and Workplace Safety and Insurance Board, Tor. Doc. #493/21 ( Div. Ct.)
PO-4053 Affected party’s application for judicial review  issued Jan 28, 2021

Abandoned by the Applicant (June 2021)

K-Bro Linen Systems Inc. v. (Ontario) Information and Privacy Commissioner, Sinai Health System and Jane Doe, Requester Toronto Div.Ct. Doc. No. 079/21
PO-4031 Affected party’s application for judicial review pending K-Bro Linen Systems Inc. v. (Ontario) Information and Privacy Commissioner and William Osler Health System – Brampton Campus, Toronto Div.Ct. Doc. No. (not assigned)
PO-3922 and PO-4021-R Institution’s  and Affected Third Party’s applications for judicial review now pending York University Development Corporation v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, York University and John * Doe/Janes Doe, Requesters, Toronto Div.Ct. Doc. 133/20
*and*
York University v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, York University Development Corporation and John * Doe/Janes Doe, Requesters, Toronto Div.Ct. Doc. 134/20
PO-3999 Requesters application for judicial review pending Van De Wiele and McLellan vs. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, The Ministry of the Solicitor General, The Ontario Provincial Police, et al..  London Div.Ct. Doc 59/19
PO-3960-R of
PO-3617
Affected parties’ application for judicial review of the reconsideration decision pending Dr. A.B. v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, The Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care and Theresa Boyle, Tor. Doc. 323/19 (Div. Ct.)
PO-3973 Attorney General’s appeal of the Divisional Court’s decision to the Court of Appeal for Ontario pending Attorney General for Ontario v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario and Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, Tor. Doc. 456/19 (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court Decision

Leave to appeal decision

PO-3955 Affected party’s application for judicial review pending Bruce Power v. Information and Privacy Commissioner and Independent Electricity Systems Operator, et al., Tor. Doc. 315/16 (Div. Ct.)
PO-3841 and
PO-3870-R
Affected party’s application for judicial review pending Swift River Energy Limited v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, Tor. Doc. 531/18
PO-3740 Requester’s application dismissed

Judicial Review application was dismissed from the Bench at the hearing on Dec 13, 2018 with $1,500 in costs awarded to Carleton University

Lyne Brassard v. Carleton University and Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, Ottawa Doc. DC-17-2309 (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3691 Requester’s application dismissed on March 27, 2018 Williams and Price v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, Tor. Doc. 200/17 (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3686 Requester’s application pending Denis Rancourt v. University of Ottawa, Ottawa Doc. 17-2279 (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court handwritten endorsement (dated November 22, 2018)

PO-3663 Affected party’s application pending Gartner Inc. v. Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, Treasury Board Secretariat and Jane Doe, Requester, Tor. Doc. 559/16 (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3620 Institution’s application abandoned on May 3, 2017 Lambton College of Applied Arts and Technology v. Information and Privacy Commissioner (Ontario), Tor. Doc. 349/16 (Div. Ct.)
PO-3617 Affected parties’ applications dismissed on June 30, 2017

Affected parties’ appeal dismissed August 3, 2018

Affected parties’ application for leave to appeal in the Supreme Court denied
April 11, 2019

Ontario Medical Association v. Information and Privacy Commissioner for Ontario, the Honourable Eric Hoskins, Minister of Health and Long-term Care, the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care and Theresa Boyle,Tor. Doc. 305/16 (Div. Ct.)
&
Several Physicians affected directly by the Order v.  Information and Privacy Commissioner for Ontario, the Honourable Eric Hoskins, Minister of Health and Long-Term Care, the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care and Theresa Boyle, Tor. Doc. 306/16 (Div. Ct.)
&
Affected Third Party Doctors v. Theresa Boyle (Requestor), Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, the Honourable Eric Hoskins Minister of Health and Long-Term Care (Respondent Head), Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care (Institution),
Tor. Doc. 312/16 (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

Court of Appeal decision

Supreme Court of Canada (leave)

PO-3576 Institution’s JR application dismissed on June 13, 2018 Carleton University v. Information and Privacy Commissioner and John Doe, Requestor, Ottawa Doc.16-2207 (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3598 Affected party’s application dismissed on March 17, 2017 The Toronto-Dominion Bank v. Ryerson University, John Doe Requestor and the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, 2017 ONSC 1507 (CanLII), (Div. Ct.), motion for leave to appeal dismissed June 14, 2017 (C.A. M47677)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3520 Institution’s application dismissed on February 2, 2017

Appeal granted by the Court of Appeal for Ontario on June 18, 2018

IPC leave application dismissed by the Supreme Court of Canada on March 28, 2019

Children’s Lawyer for Ontario v. Information and Privacy Commissioner/Ontario and the Ministry of the Attorney General for Ontario, and John Doe, Requester, 2017 ONSC 642 (CanLII), (Div. Ct.), motion for leave to appeal granted May 12, 2017 (C.A. M47541)

Divisional Court decision

Court of Appeal decision

Supreme Court of Canada judgement

PO-3514 Institution’s application dismissed on November 15, 2016 Ministry of the Attorney General v. Information and Privacy Commissioner and Marcus McCann, 2016 ONSC 6913 (CanLII), (Div. Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3472 Affected parties’ applications allowed on August 22, 2016 Trustees of the Bricklayers and Stonemasons Union Local 2 Ontario Pension Plan v. Information and Privacy Commissioner, The Minister of Finance, and the Financial Services Commission of Ontario, 2016 ONSC 3821 (CanLII), (Div. Ct.), motion for leave to appeal dismissed December 12, 2016 (C.A. M46922)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3392 Affected party’s application dismissed on March 7, 2016 Accenture Inc. v. Ontario (Information and Privacy Commissioner) and Metrolinx, 2016 ONSC 1616 (CanLII), (Div.Ct.), motion for leave to appeal dismissed June 23, 2016 (C.A. M46285)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3322-I
PO-3231-I
PO-3402-F
Applicant’s application allowed on November 15, 2016 and remitted back to the IPC The Criminal Lawyers’ Association v. The Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services and Brian Beamish, Commissioner (Acting), Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, 2016 ONSC 6948 (CanLII), (Div.Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

PO-3074 &
PO-3132
Requester’s application dismissed on February 14,  2017 John R. Mann III v. Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Ontario as represented by the Ministry of Environment and the Information and Privacy Commissioner for Ontario, 2017 ONSC 1056 (CanLII), (Div.Ct.)

Divisional Court decision

This post is also available in: French